Why most grad school applications land in the middle (and how to stand out)


Happy Friday, Reader, you made it!

For a few weeks, we’ve zoomed in on different sections of personal statements. This week, we’re taking a 20,000-foot view of your whole application.


Admit It: You’ve reread your application so many times you can’t tell whether it’s good or if you want to burn it and start over.

This is totally normal when you’re almost there. What’s likely happening: your application is fine.

But the goal isn’t fine. It’s accepted.

Something that surprised me over a decade of reading applications: very few are super strong or severely lacking. Basically, I saw a handful of auto-accepts and another handful of auto-rejects out of hundreds each year.

(FYI, the auto-rejects were completely misaligned with the program or missing key components of essays or experience. If you’re reading this newsletter each week, it’s highly unlikely you’ll fall in that camp.)

This means that the majority are in the middle. The applicants are usually qualified, but their full application may be disjointed or unclear.

So what does "the middle" look like?

  • The related experience is there on the resume, but the reviewer has to make the connection to the program when reading the personal statement.
  • The statement says what they did, but not what it prepared them to do in graduate school or their future career.
  • Each piece of the application (resume, letters of recommendation, personal statement, transcripts) tells a slightly different story, especially for applicants who are pivoting careers.

I’ve especially seen this with dual-degree applications that have a single personal statement. It’s usually easier to speak at length about one of the programs, which makes reviewers wonder what the draw is for the second one. A lot of intentionality is needed to connect past experiences to each degree and a career plan that utilizes both.

If you’re feeling a little uncertain or want to do a temperature check of your own application to see if it’s in middle territory, here are your action steps to stand out:

Action Step 1: Write your purpose in one sentence.

“I’m ready for [program] because [evidence], and I’ll use this degree to [career goal after graduation].”

Real talk here: you need to be able to complete this sentence so you have a clear why as a reference point for your application. Think of it like an elevator pitch for graduate school.

Here's a "mid" example:

  • "I'm ready for this MPP program because I've seen how policy affects communities firsthand, and I'll use this degree to advocate for better policies."

And here's the detailed, standout version:

  • "I'm ready for the Master of Public Policy because I spent three years managing a housing navigation program at a local nonprofit, where I traced 40% of our families' evictions to a single eligibility gap in the state's rental assistance rules. I'll use this degree to eventually work at the Ohio Housing Finance Agency as a program and policy manager and write eligibility rules that reach families before an eviction filing."

Note: while you could use a sentence like this in your actual statement, the goal with drafting it is to have one crystal clear reference point for how your past connects to your intended program and future career.

A reviewer needs to know you have a clear why, because that why is what will carry you through to graduation. (And they only want to admit people who are likely to graduate.)

Once you have this sentence set, it becomes your guide to make sure all pieces of your application point to it.

Action Step 2: Check if every piece of your application tells the same story.

Examples:

  • Letters of Recommendation: What examples are your recommenders highlighting that align with your purpose sentence?
  • Personal Statement: Your statement should be the expanded version of the sentence.
  • Resume: Have the descriptions of your experiences been written to align with the skills your program values? (Do not submit a version of your resume that was last written for a job application.)
  • Transcript: Do the courses you’ve taken and grades you’ve earned reflect the academic expectations of your program? (If not, you have options.)

Does every part of your application make the connection? Or do they need to be more direct for a tired, late-night reviewer who may not connect the pieces for you?

Action Step 3: Get fresh eyes for a quick review and confirmation.

Ask someone you trust to give a five-minute skim of your resume and personal statement. (Bonus points if they don’t work in your field.)

After the five minutes are up, ask them one question: “Why am I applying to this program?” Compare their answer to your purpose sentence.

If the response is close to your sentence, you’re in solid shape. If they describe more of what you’ve done versus what you plan to do with your degree, you’ll know exactly what blanks need to be filled for the real reviewers.

The hardest part? Being an active listener for this activity.

Be curious and open to hear what first impressions you may be making before making adjustments to your application.


What I’m working on ✍️

It’s personal statement review season!

With November 15 and December 1 deadlines coming up, I’ve been spending evenings with printed statements, a clipboard and a green pen making notes on what’s amazing, what’s missing, what connects, and where to condense or expand. I cross-reference these with notes from emails and Zoom calls to make sure everything is covered and the applicant's voice shines through. Then I add comments to a shared Google Doc to guide their next draft, and give them the opportunity to ask questions throughout the review period.

For reapplicants, I make a point to be especially encouraging because I’ve been through the rejection process and know exactly what’s riding on this next application.

A lot of people think these reviews are about writing. In reality, the notes are all about clear connections.


Something else to consider with the purpose sentence from above: share it with your recommenders.

It will give them a better understanding of your why, which they can echo in their example choices and to describe how you’re a good fit for this program right now.

By having clarity across all parts of your application, a reviewer will understand why you’re applying and why you deserve a spot this year. And if your application goes to a committee for discussion, the biggest advocate in that room will have a clear case to make for your acceptance.

Make their job easy. You can do this.

Thanks for being here, make it a great weekend!

Dr. Jena

P.S. Wondering if you’re in the middle of the pile? I can tell you in five minutes, too. One of the first things we cover in a Personal Statement Review is the connection between your past experiences, individual programs, and your future career goals. Start with a short form, then choose a time for a free, relaxed 30-minute discussion of where you are, what you need, and ways I can support you before submitting. Think of the experience as having a thought partner to guide you forward.


Was this forwarded to you? Welcome! For weekly graduate school insights, subscribe here or browse past issues first 📩

Whenever you're ready: 1:1 Strategy Sessions · Personal Statement Reviews · Organizational Workshops & Training · Application Tracker​

1491 Polaris Pkwy #377, Columbus, OH 43240, USA
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Dr. Jena Pugh

Preparing to go for that next degree? You're in the right place. Whether you are deciding when the time is right or are applying this year, Dr. Jena shares expert insight on the entire process - plus clear action steps so you can do everything right the first time.

Read more from Dr. Jena Pugh
Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! This week, we’re talking about the part of the application that most applicants put off: writing about the rough semester, a low GPA, or an education gap you’ve moved past. Admit It: Your application is basically done, except for addressing the elephant in the room. You told yourself you’d deal with it later. Then later showed up. And now you’re staring at your personal statement or an optional essay prompt wondering how to explain a low point without...

Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! Last week, we talked about rising to the top of the “pile” of applications. This week, we’re turning the focus to who’s reading through it. Admit It: You picture your reviewer as someone in a tweed blazer at a desk in a quiet office, carefully weighing every word you wrote. I get it. I pictured that too, before I became one. Here’s what reviewing applications looked like for me for a decade: it was not sitting in the middle of a sunny afternoon, sipping...

Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! And yay for Halloween! Last week, I covered the first lines of your personal statement. This week, we’re jumping to the end. Admit It: Your current personal statement ends with “Thank you for your consideration.” (I’m pretty sure mine did, too.) And it makes sense conceptually. You’re “meeting” someone on paper, and essentially asking them for something major before even meeting in person. Saying thank you can feel like the only polite and appropriate way to...