Happy Friday, Reader, you made it!
This week, we’re talking about the part of the application that most applicants put off: writing about the rough semester, a low GPA, or an education gap you’ve moved past.
Admit It: Your application is basically done, except for addressing the elephant in the room.
You told yourself you’d deal with it later. Then later showed up.
And now you’re staring at your personal statement or an optional essay prompt wondering how to explain a low point without drawing a giant circle around it.
I’ve been there. If you read about my junior year back in September (I was a resident assistant, cheerleader, part-time coach, volunteer, then got straight C’s), you know I learned this one the slow way when it came time to apply for a master’s. My first application cycle didn’t go as planned.
What I didn’t know then as a first-generation student: a graduate program’s minimum GPA is usually a minimum threshold, not a simple checkbox.
When you’re on the low end of a requirement, reviewers expect you to explain it.
Flash forward to when I became a reviewer. I saw every kind of explanation. Some over-explained. Some apologized when they didn’t need to. The worst blamed someone or something else.
(Accountability is a must in graduate school.)
There’s a difference between blaming a circumstance and stating it. Reviewers aren’t looking for an apology, either. They want to see that the experience is behind you.
When you’re honest and brief about a rough season (like a death in the family, working 40+ hours a week on top of a full course load, or pausing school to take care of life), there isn’t much to argue with. Especially when the rest of your application shows it was temporary and you’re in a different spot now.
Here are your action steps for writing about it without apologizing:
Action Step 1: Figure out where it belongs before you write anything.
If your GPA is below the program’s minimum, talk to admissions first. You don’t want to spend months on an application that won’t even be considered. Many programs review applications holistically and may simply ask for a short essay so they know you’re ready for graduate school now.
If there’s an optional or supplemental essay, that’s usually the best home for this, so your personal statement can stay focused on where you’re headed. If the program asks you to address it in your personal statement, keep it to two or three sentences max and then move forward.
Action Step 2: Fully write out what happened, then keep only the facts.
Start by writing or voice memo-ing what was going on at that time, why it was so difficult, and how it showed up in your academic record (your grades, a withdrawal, time away from school). Let yourself say how it felt. Then go back and drill down to the facts. “I was working 35 hours a week, commuting an hour each way on top of school full-time” says more than a paragraph about feeling overwhelmed.
Mid example: “My grades weren’t what they should have been that semester. I know it doesn’t reflect well on me, and I struggled for a lot of reasons.”
Standout example: “During the fall of my junior year, I overextended myself. I was a resident assistant, a cheerleader, a part-time coach, and a volunteer while taking four courses in my major. My grades reflected it. I adjusted my commitments that spring, and my grades steadily improved through graduation.”
If a dip in grades or gap in education involved your mental health, you can name it, but keep it brief and focus on the steps you took to get to a better place to succeed academically. How much detail fits depends on the field: counseling, social work, or psychology programs may welcome more of that context than a business or law school will.
Action Step 3: End with what you’ll do or keep doing as a graduate student.
Reviewers want to see three things:
- That you acknowledge what happened
- What you did about it (once you could)
- What you’ll continue to do
Most applicants stop after the second one.
Name the changes you made (going to office hours, getting a tutor, retaking a course, cutting back on time-intensive commitments), then connect them to the program you’re applying to. If you’re the type of person who introduces yourself at office hours in the first two weeks of class, say that. You can even name the writing center or a faculty member you hope to connect with. A reviewer can’t assume any of this unless you tell them.
What I’m working on ✍️
I’m heading into a building season of refreshing my website and streamlining what I offer for individuals and organizations so it’s easier for people to learn how we can work together.
The piece I keep circling back to is my About page. How much of my own story belongs there? The rejection? That junior-year semester? Turns out I’m taking my own advice from this week: name it, keep it brief, and spend the rest of the space on what came next.
To be honest, this building season gives me the same mix of feelings my applicants have: sheer excitement and the slight stomach drop of “wow, this will be a lot of work.” It’ll definitely be worth it!
So why does this matter?
Because a rough patch is part of your story, not the whole thing, even if it felt all-consuming at the time. When you address it directly, it becomes proof that you know how to adjust if challenges pop up in the future. (Programs want to admit resilient people who will make it to graduation.)
If I could give advice to my early-20s self anxiously applying a second time, it would be to own my experiences and move forward. That junior-year semester was a wake-up call that set me on a much clearer path and ultimately prepared me for the intensity of graduate school once I was ready.
A challenging period leading to growth is often what graduate school is, this is your chance to prove to yourself and your reviewers that you can do it again.
Make it a great weekend!
Dr. Jena
P.S. Spending the holidays getting your applications in order? Based on the emails I’m getting, you’re in great company! My Ultimate Application Tracker keeps your statement prompts, recommendation letter writers, transcripts, and scholarship opportunities in one place, so you’re not constantly Googling and tab-switching to find what you need.
Starting today, it’s $19 (usually $27) through Dec. 1 with code TRACKER26. Grab it here.
Have a friend or mentee applying this year? Forward this email and show you’re thinking of them. And if you’d like to gift the tracker to someone you know (or an AmeriCorps member on a limited stipend), just hit reply and we’ll get a copy to the person who needs it most.