What it’s like to be a reviewer


Happy Friday, Reader, you made it!

Last week, we talked about rising to the top of the “pile” of applications. This week, we’re turning the focus to who’s reading through it.


Admit It: You picture your reviewer as someone in a tweed blazer at a desk in a quiet office, carefully weighing every word you wrote.

I get it. I pictured that too, before I became one.

Here’s what reviewing applications looked like for me for a decade: it was not sitting in the middle of a sunny afternoon, sipping consistently hot tea, and making decisions about people’s futures. It actually looked like melting into my couch at 10:00pm, the only time I could focus for two straight hours without a single email or text interruption.

In the dead of winter, I was lying in a hoodie with a laptop on my stomach, scrolling through countless 10-page PDFs and making notes on a spreadsheet, with Hilary Duff’s “Sparks” on a one-hour loop in the background. (That song got me through application season for years!)

I share this because reviewers are human.

They wake up, get dressed, go out in the world, and have a to-do list that always exceeds the number of hours in the day, just like the rest of us. And when application season hits, they’re reading on top of their normal workload after a full day of work. If they’re faculty, add teaching and grading, too.

What most applicants don’t realize: You’ve painstakingly put your application together in tiny little pieces over months and months. Your reviewer gets one PDF of everything you submitted and reads it all at once.

And truthfully? It gets skimmed in a matter of minutes.

That’s not a reason to panic. It’s a reason to be strategic. A tired reviewer at the end of a long day isn’t usually hunting for reasons to say no.

They’re looking to be excited by someone.

Here are your action steps to make that someone you:

Action Step 1: Read your application the way it will actually be read.

Combine everything (resume, personal statement, transcripts, any supplemental essays) into a single document for yourself. Wait until the end of a long day, get comfortable, and read it top to bottom in one sitting. Set a timer for ten minutes.

When the timer goes off, ask yourself: could I find my purpose sentence from last week? If you had to hunt for it, so will your reviewer… and they may not have the energy with 20 more applications to go through by tomorrow.

Action Step 2: Swap hesitant language for forward-looking language.

When I was reading late at night, I was looking for positive language and forward thinking. Scan your statement for phrases like “I hope to,” “I think I might,” “I believe I,” or “although I don’t have much experience.” Then rewrite them around what you’re ready for and what you’ll do.

Mid example: “Although I don’t have a research background, I hope to learn more about evaluation.”

Standout example: “Coordinating a tutoring program for two years taught me to track student outcomes, and I’m ready to turn that into formal evaluation skills.”

Action Step 3: Show you’ve made the most of the opportunities you were given.

Something else I watched for: evidence that someone had said yes to the opportunities in front of them. If they’d done it before, I trusted they’d do it with what my program offered.

Make a quick list. It could include a training you raised your hand for, a project you volunteered to lead, a mentor you sought out, or a role that grew because you asked for more. Pick one or two that connect to your purpose sentence and make sure they’re easy to spot in your statement. (Bonus: this is also proof you’ve done hard things. Programs want to admit people who are going to make it to graduation.)


What I’m working on ✍️

Nov. 8 was national First-Generation College Celebration Day for students and alumni who were the first in their family to graduate with a bachelor’s degree. Yay! As a first-gen student myself, I spent the weekend celebrating with the places that helped me get there.

It started with an alumni weekend at Denison University, where I connected with the current cheerleading team. (It’s probably no surprise I was a cheerleader for 10+ years 📣.) I also talked with current students about their post-graduation plans and when graduate school might make sense. The next day, I had lunch at The Ohio State University - where I was a first-gen master’s and doctoral student - with young alumni from my high school. That’s where my advisor made it his mission to make sure I found and got into a college I’d love. It was a whirlwind 48 hours of nostalgia and learning about the next generation.

Before the festivities, I also wrapped up a final personal statement review for a reapplicant who’s submitting their application in the next week! I’m beyond excited for them and what comes next.

Moral of the story: The people who opened doors for me cared deeply about who walked through them. So does your reviewer.


So why does knowing the reviewer’s experience matter?

Because your application isn’t read the way you wrote it. You built it piece by piece over months. Your reviewer reads it all at once, sometimes in the wee hours, hoping to be excited by someone. When your purpose, your experiences, and your future plans are easy to find, you give them exactly what they’re hoping for.

Before you hit submit (a week early, for your own sanity), give your application one more read as that tired, hopeful person on the couch. If it makes them sit up a little, you’re in great shape.

Thanks for being here. Make it a great weekend!

Dr. Jena

P.S. Want a reviewer’s read before the real one? That’s what a Personal Statement Review is for. I read your statement the way a reviewer will, then tell you what’s amazing, what’s missing, and what to sharpen before your deadline. Start with a short form, then choose a time for a free, relaxed 30-minute discussion. (Sweats optional. Hilary Duff background music available upon request


Was this forwarded to you? Welcome! For weekly graduate school insights, subscribe here or browse past issues first 📩

Whenever you're ready: 1:1 Strategy Sessions · Personal Statement Reviews · Organizational Workshops & Training · Application Tracker​

1491 Polaris Pkwy #377, Columbus, OH 43240, USA
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Dr. Jena Pugh

Preparing to go for that next degree? You're in the right place. Whether you are deciding when the time is right or are applying this year, Dr. Jena shares expert insight on the entire process - plus clear action steps so you can do everything right the first time.

Read more from Dr. Jena Pugh
Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! This week, we’re talking about the part of the application that most applicants put off: writing about the rough semester, a low GPA, or an education gap you’ve moved past. Admit It: Your application is basically done, except for addressing the elephant in the room. You told yourself you’d deal with it later. Then later showed up. And now you’re staring at your personal statement or an optional essay prompt wondering how to explain a low point without...

Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! For a few weeks, we’ve zoomed in on different sections of personal statements. This week, we’re taking a 20,000-foot view of your whole application. Admit It: You’ve reread your application so many times you can’t tell whether it’s good or if you want to burn it and start over. This is totally normal when you’re almost there. What’s likely happening: your application is fine. But the goal isn’t fine. It’s accepted. Something that surprised me over a decade...

Text reads Admit It. with Dr. Jena, including a hand-drawn graduation cap over the A.

Happy Friday, Reader, you made it! And yay for Halloween! Last week, I covered the first lines of your personal statement. This week, we’re jumping to the end. Admit It: Your current personal statement ends with “Thank you for your consideration.” (I’m pretty sure mine did, too.) And it makes sense conceptually. You’re “meeting” someone on paper, and essentially asking them for something major before even meeting in person. Saying thank you can feel like the only polite and appropriate way to...